Religion (Was Re: Music)

Don Smith don_smith at att.net
Fri Jun 14 10:30:34 PDT 2002


Archaic wrote:
> 
> On Fri, Jun 14, 2002 at 11:08:55AM -0400, Don Smith wrote:
> > I do not know what is the right thing to do. How do you resolve the
> > Freedom of Speech vs. Freedom of Religion? I lean towards Freedom of
> > Speech since that freedom is absolutely essential in maintaining all the
> > other freedoms.
> 
> They can go hand in hand. The concept of freedom of speech is a
> guarantee (supposedly) that says you can freely express yourself.
> However, in larger contexts, your freedoms stop where another's begin.
> Therefore, in order for you to be able to freely express yourself, I
> must also be able to freely excuse myself from your presence. In
> schools, I cannot freely excuse myself so the bubble of freedom you are
> wrapped in has to be temporarily shrunken to allow for not stepping into
> the bubble of others rights. That's how religion fits in. Obviously, if
> I should accidently walk into a church (pick your favorite denomination)
> and say, "Whoa! I don't like this", I can freely walk out. If I go to
> school and the teacher starts leading a prayer, I can't. Of course,
> things are taken WAY out of proprtion (as always). Example: my friends
> and I want to pray before class. We do not force people to participate,
> there is no obstruction of their freedoms. That example should be
> allowed. A teacher or faculty member, on the other hand, during school
> hours, is a representative of the government, and should refrain. But
> you can read my other post to see what I think about that.
> 
Nothing I can disagree with here. But, for the sake of argument, do we
allow Santeria's (to pick an absurdly extreme example) to sacrifice
chickens in the corner before each class? And I'm sure Satanists doing
there thing would be extremely offensive to the Christians in the room.

Don
-- 
Unsubscribe: send email to listar at linuxfromscratch.org
and put 'unsubscribe lfs-chat' in the subject header of the message



More information about the lfs-chat mailing list