Reorganizing the book

Bruce Dubbs bdubbs at
Tue Mar 23 17:13:45 PST 2004

Tushar Teredesai wrote:

> LFS moved from putting the init scripts in the book to making a 
> package out of it and installing the lfs-bootscriptss package instead. 
> If you are suggesting that the bootscripts be included in the BLFS 
> book, then they should also be included in the LFS book since IMO the 
> init scripts in LFS have more educational value than BLFS. (Most of 
> the BLFS init scripts fall in "run_proc server_executable" for 
> starting and "kill_proc server_executable" category which IMO is very 
> uninteresting.)

It looks like LFS changed from having the scripts to a package around 
version 3.2 -- (2001?)
Looking back, I'm not sure that was the right way to go.  I don't have a 
problem with having the scripts in a package, but I do think the book 
lost something from an educational point of view.  Doing both would be 
reasonable.  Glancing at version 3.1, I do think the scripts needed to 
be explained a bit better.  inittab was good, but rc and the other 
scripts were a bit light.

If the full script was omitted and the startup, shutdown, reload lines 
are in the appropriate sections, I could go along with that, but just 
referring to a package loses too much educational info.

  -- Bruce

More information about the blfs-dev mailing list